About Us
Fresh Custom Cookies and Cakes made to order just for you!
We're thrilled to announce that our small in-home bakery in the Columbus, Ohio area is back in business! Since 2015, we've had the pleasure of serving our wonderful local community with handmade custom cookies and personalized cakes, including our popular custom sugar cookies in Columbus, Ohio.
Though Covid pressed pause on our baking adventures for a moment, we're excited to be back, bringing you delicious treats that add sweetness to your special occasions. If you're looking for custom cookies in Columbus or custom cookies in Columbus, Ohio, you've come to the right place!
Connect with us on Facebook for a glimpse into our tasty creations, behind-the-scenes moments, and more! Follow us at Mmmgoodness Cookies on Facebook for the latest updates and mouthwatering ideas.
Thank you for your continued support. We can't wait to bake up some Mmmgoodness for you! 🍪✨
#MmmgoodnessCookies #LocalBakery #ColumbusOhio #BackInBusiness
Custom Cookies and Cakes
By offering both handmade custom cookies in Columbus, Ohio and personalized cakes, your services cater to a variety of tastes, occasions, and preferences. The combination of quality, customization, and a customer-centric approach is likely to make your bakery the go-to choice for those seeking custom sugar cookies in Columbus, Ohio, as well as custom cookies that truly stand out.
Photo Gallery
Price List
Important to know...
We are excited to create custom cookies in Columbus, Ohio for your event, but pictures and clear descriptions are the best! All orders, including our custom sugar cookies in Columbus, Ohio, will vary in pricing, so the pricing listed is a standard starting price and the minimum order pricing for cookie and cake orders.
Shipping
Shipping is available for cookie orders only, including our popular custom cookies in Columbus, Ohio. Each cookie will be individually bubble wrapped, ensuring the utmost safety for the safest travel. Please note that we do not replace or refund damaged cookies from the mail. You can order individual cookies for $4.00 each, specifically for shipping orders with a minimum of 2 dozen custom sugar cookies from Columbus, Ohio. Cakes and other sweet treats will be available for pick up or delivery. Delivery is only available within a 30-mile radius from the 43228 zip code.
Allergy Disclaimer
Please note that the food prepared here, including our delicious custom cookies Columbus Ohio, may come in contact with or contain peanuts, tree nuts, soy, eggs, wheat, and dairy. This applies to all our baked goods, such as custom sugar cookies Columbus Ohio, ensuring you are aware of potential allergens.
Return Policy
All cookies, including our custom cookies in Columbus, Ohio, will be inspected at the time of delivery or pick up. If there are any cookies that are broken, such as our custom sugar cookies from Columbus, Ohio, we will be happy to replace or credit you for the individual cookies. However, we are not responsible for and will not replace or credit any item once it has been delivered or picked up. You are responsible for the safe transportation of your items, including any custom cookies from Columbus, and no credits or replacements will be issued after delivery or pick up.
Cookies do break...
Cookies do break, so if you feel your cookies from Columbus, Ohio may break during your transportation process, please order a few extra. You may choose to waive inspection; if you do so, no credit or replacements will be issued under any circumstances. Please also note that GOLDEN BROWN is NOT BURNT! If you wish to have custom cookies in Columbus that are not Golden Brown, please indicate this on your order. Keep in mind that this makes the cookie more fragile, and no replacements will be provided for any custom sugar cookies from Columbus, Ohio that crumble.
Custom Sugar Cookies
Golden buttery baked fresh sugar cookies with delicious royal icing are a treat for the senses, especially when you’re in Columbus, Ohio. Whether they're shaped into festive holiday figures, delicate flowers, or simple rounds, custom sugar cookies from Columbus, Ohio, are a classic and versatile treat that appeals to many. The smooth, glossy finish of the royal icing adds an extra layer of sweetness and a touch of artistry to each cookie, making these custom cookies in Columbus truly special.
Basic Sugar Cookies - minimum 1 dozen
$36/dozen
Basic sugar cookies from Columbus, Ohio, come in 1-3 designs, and we are ready to create delicious and visually appealing custom cookies. Whether you're looking for custom sugar cookies in Columbus, Ohio, or unique custom cookies, we have you covered.
Custom Sugar Cookie Set
$45/doz and Up
Creating custom sugar cookies in Columbus, Ohio, with a variety of shapes and colors is a wonderful idea for special occasions! Whether it's birthdays, weddings, holidays, or any other celebration, these custom cookies from Columbus add a unique and memorable touch to the festivities. Starting at $45.00 a dozen for custom cookies Columbus Ohio.
Basic Specialty Cake
$50
Celebrate Sweetly with Mmm Goodness Whether you're marking a birthday, anniversary, or any special milestone, a custom specialty cake brings a personal and delicious touch to your celebration. Choose your favorite flavor, filling, and enjoy a beautifully crafted 6-inch round, 4-layer cake topped with our signature buttercream frosting—a treat as delightful as the occasion itself.
✨ Want to make it even more memorable? Add a set of custom sugar cookies designed to match your theme! We welcome your ideas and preferences to create desserts that reflect your unique style. Customization options are available for both cakes and cookies for an additional fee.
Customized Specialty Cake
$85 and Up
A customized specialty cake isn’t just dessert—it’s the centerpiece of your celebration. Whether you prefer a simple, elegant design or an elaborate themed creation, our cakes are crafted to reflect your unique style and elevate your event.
Our signature 6-inch, 4-layer cake includes your choice of flavor and filling, all wrapped in luscious buttercream frosting for a perfect balance of taste and visual appeal.
🍪 Looking to sweeten the experience even more? Pair your cake with our delightful custom sugar cookies—handcrafted in Columbus, Ohio—to create a cohesive and delicious dessert spread that guests will rave about.
2 Layered Alphabet or Number Cake
$50 and Up
Celebrate with Style: Custom Letter & Number Cakes Add a meaningful and eye-catching centerpiece to your celebration with a personalized two-layer letter or number cake. These unique creations combine visual impact with heartfelt personalization, making them perfect for birthdays, anniversaries, graduations, and more.
Crafted in your favorite flavor and finished with our signature buttercream, each cake is as delicious as it is memorable.
🍪 Want to take it up a notch? Pair your cake with custom cookies—whether classic sugar cookies or themed designs—all handcrafted in Columbus, Ohio. Together, they create a stunning dessert experience that blends flavor, elegance, and personal flair.
Basic Cupcakes
$18/dozen
Sweet Simplicity Meets Custom Charm Enjoy classic cupcakes in a variety of flavors, topped with rich buttercream frosting—perfect for any occasion. Pair them with our handcrafted custom sugar cookies and other delightful cookie creations, all made with care right here in Columbus, Ohio. It’s a delicious way to add flavor, fun, and a personal touch to your celebration.
Specialty Cupcakes
$24/dozen
Enjoy our delightful cupcakes featuring a variety of flavors, fillings, and buttercream frosting, beautifully decorated for your special event. Don't forget to check out our custom cookies in Columbus, Ohio, including custom sugar cookies that can be tailored to your theme.
Macarons
$18 - $33/dozen
Macarons are delightful and versatile French pastries known for their delicate, meringue-like shells and creamy fillings. The variety of flavors they come in makes them a popular choice for both standalone treats and creative additions to other desserts. In Columbus, Ohio, these macarons can be found alongside custom cookies, including custom sugar cookies that cater to various tastes. They are sold in sets of 6 for $18.00 or 12 for $33.00.
Dipped Krispy Treats
$24-$36/dozen
Candy-dipped crispy treats are a fantastic and versatile treat that can be enjoyed on a variety of occasions. Whether you're serving them at a celebration, giving them as a gift, or simply enjoying them as a sweet treat, these candy-dipped crispy treats bring a delightful combination of chewiness and sweetness that appeals to a wide audience. If you're looking for something even more special, consider our custom cookies in Columbus, Ohio. Basic designs start at $24.00 a dozen where shaped designs start at $36.00 a dozen, including our popular custom sugar cookies from Columbus, Ohio.
Dipped Pretzel Rods
$15/dozen
Whether enjoyed as a snack, a party favor, or a sweet gift, chocolate-dipped pretzel rods offer a delightful combination of flavors and textures that make them a favorite for many occasions, just like the custom cookies Columbus residents love for their events. Whether you're looking for custom sugar cookies Columbus Ohio has to offer or unique custom cookies Columbus, these treats can elevate any gathering.
Cake Pop
$24-$36/dozen
Cake pops are not only delicious but also a fun and versatile treat that can be customized to suit a variety of flavors and themes for special events, much like the custom cookies Columbus Ohio offers. Basic round cake pops start at $24.00 a dozen, while shaped themed cake pops, similar to custom sugar cookies Columbus Ohio, start at $36.00 a dozen.
For inquiries about our delicious cookies in Columbus, Ohio, including custom cookies and custom sugar cookies, feel free to email us at mmmgoodnesscookies.com or call 614-284-7598.
Contact Us for a Quote!
Mmm Goodness Cookies and Treats
This website uses cookies.
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.